Naples has more strong luxury communities than almost any market its size, which is exactly why choosing one is hard. The right community depends on your lifestyle, your budget, and whether you want new construction or established resale. Four that I work in often, and recommend most, are Isles of Collier Preserve, Fiddler’s Creek, Treviso Bay, and Caymas. Here is who each one suits.
A naturalist’s luxury community built around the Cypress Waterway, with miles of kayak and paddle trails, a resort clubhouse, and a coastal contemporary architectural style. It draws buyers who want privacy, preserve and water views, and an active outdoor lifestyle close to Old Naples. Prices reach into the multimillions for waterfront and larger estate homes. If you want nature and elegance over a golf first lifestyle, this is the one to tour.
A large, amenity rich master planned community anchored by the Club and Spa, multiple resort pools, a fitness and spa campus, and golf and beach memberships. It blends new and recent construction across a range of villages and price points, which makes it flexible for everyone from seasonal owners to full time families who want a country club lifestyle without leaving the gate.
A guard gated, resort style community built around a TPC golf course, with a Tuscan inspired clubhouse, spa, tennis, and resort pools. It suits buyers who want a true golf and country club lifestyle, whether that is a full membership home or a lock and leave seasonal residence. Understanding the membership structure is key here, and it is something I walk buyers through carefully.
One of Naples’ most sought after new construction communities, 500 homes on 700 lakefront acres, anchored by a 30,000 square foot clubhouse and an 18 acre amenity campus. Pulte homes start at $839,990, Stock homes start at $1,500,000, and larger custom estates rise well past $3,000,000. Caymas is the right tour for buyers who want brand new construction, modern floor plans, and resort amenities, without waiting years for an established community to mature. See the full Caymas community guide for details.
Start with lifestyle. Golf first points to Treviso Bay. Nature and water point to Isles of Collier Preserve. Full service amenities across price points point to Fiddler’s Creek. Brand new construction points to Caymas. Then layer in budget, timeline, and fee structure. I help buyers compare them honestly, including the parts builders and brochures gloss over.
Among the strongest are Isles of Collier Preserve, Fiddler’s Creek, Treviso Bay, and Caymas. The best one for you depends on lifestyle, budget, and whether you want new construction or established resale.
Caymas is the most requested new construction community right now, with resort level amenities, Pulte homes from $839,990, and Stock homes from $1,500,000.
Treviso Bay is built around a TPC golf course with a full country club lifestyle, while Fiddler’s Creek offers golf memberships alongside broader resort amenities.
Get it in your inbox
One letter a month with the Naples numbers and what I am seeing on the ground. No listing blasts. Unsubscribe anytime.
Whether you are buying into one of these communities or selling a home in one, I will give you an honest comparison and a plan. Call 239.450.6206 or start with one of these.
